- 2019: Eliana Pipes: DREAMHOU$E
- 2018: Gina Femia: ALLOND(R)A
- 2017: Susan Soon He Stanton, We, The Invisibles
- 2016: Genne Murphy, Giantess
- 2015: Boo Killebrew, Miller, Mississippi
- 2014: Jen Silverman, The Moors
- 2013: Jiehae Park, Hannah and the Dread Gazebo
- 2012: Rachel Teagle, The Ever and After
- 2011: Laura Marks, Bethany
- 2010: Megan Mostyn-Brown, The Rest of Your Life
